Wan Azmi - A Bee On the Bonnet
(Freemalaysia fw)
http://www.freemalaysia.com/wan_azmi.htm
Wan Azmi:Loyal to a fault
On his own, Tan Sri Wan Azmi Wan Hamzah could have been a dynamic
businessman in just about any market economy -- but not in Malaysia, not by
himself.
No, in freeMalaysia country, most top-tier corporate players must play
multiple political cards - and pay for them all - to ascend into the ranks
of Malaysia's Fortune 100 or so. Never has that been more the Malaysian
business reality than under the crony economy engineered by Mahathir Mohamad.
The price of admission varies, but it's never cheap. Some corporate players
hedge their bets among several political patrons, despite the higher cost.
Others, including most of the leading Malay entrepreneurs, are more
beholden to a single patron. In tandem with their patron-protectors, these
Bumiputera businessmen ascend the corporate ladder; and they usually tumble
when their patrons stumble.
Wan Azmi has enough sense to see the value of hedging his political bets
for long-term corporate stability. But he didn't. Instead, he stayed by his
main patron, two-time Finance Minister Tun Daim Zainuddin.
In that sense, Wan Azmi could be a character in a modernized version of the
Malay Annals: The smart and ever grateful adjutant, who concedes no wrong
in his former master's excesses and even publicly professes his admiration
for his contributions to Malaysia. He acknowledges that he owes much to his
mentor for giving him the key to the upper business echelons, and he
remains grateful, even when the relationship starts to damage his business
and professional future.
Still, one wonders if Wan Azmi could have been more, done more, advanced
Malaysia more, and achieved a whole lot other mores, if only he didn't
succumb to the fool's golden handcuffs of Malaysia's crony capitalism.
That's the tragedy of Wan Azmi and of every other worthy Malaysian
businessman and entrepreneur who succumbs to a system that extracts maximum
gains for the few at the expense of the many.
Given the near unshakeable status of Malaysia's crony corporate system,
it's hard to find a mountain of fault with Wan Azmi. His is a bittersweet
success story about a guy who has worked hard, studied hard and learned
some hard lessons, both professional and personal. It's more than most Daim
protégés have to tell.
Still, Wan Azmi will never be able to say he did it his way, his own way.
And Malaysian corporate history won't be able to prove otherwise.
Wan Azmi's friends say he is bright, engaging, even fun in casual
conversation. Business acquaintances say that he knows his stuff and that
he usually deals fairly with them. His employees say he's a classy but
demanding boss with a big heart.
Some friends say Wan Azmi has a justifiably large ego; others say that it
can be insufferably large. A few say he's too witty and sarcastic about the
political establishment for his own good. Some even say that he's too damn
honest for his own good. But NONE say that Wan Azmi would have been what he
is today had he not played ball with Daim.
Wan Azmi has never, ever disagreed with the last point. He even once
satirically compared Daim and himself to Batman and Robin, swooping down at
night upon Kuala Lumpur's Golden Triangle district and grabbing for
themselves Malaysia's richest corporate deals. For a while, this wasn't far
from the truth.
An accountant, as are so many of Daim's protégés, Wan Azmi abruptly left
The New Straits Times Group in 1978, where he was financial controller,
after apparently having had a clash with Dato' Junus Sudin, who was then
chairman of the United Malays National Organization's corporate empire
under Fleet Holdings. It wasn't a smart career move. Junus, whose political
patron at the time was Finance Minister Tengku Razaleigh Hamzah, was as
much the corporate kingpin of his day as Daim is today.
Longtime Daim corporate proxy Desa Pachi stepped in to help Wan Azmi get
back onto the corporate fast track by arranging a job interview for him
with Daim, a man whom Wan Azmi had never met and was only vaguely aware of.
Wan Azmi, to his astonishment, was hired on the spot -- even before the
interview was completed -- as general manager of Peremba Bhd., the newly
privatized management arm of the government-owned Urban Development Corp.
It was at Peremba that Daim assembled the corporate corps of protégés that
would serve him to this day. Some of them, such as Halim Saad and Samsudin
Abu Hassan, freeMalaysia has already profiled; others, such as Razali
Rahman and Hassan Abbas, may have their day. The idea was to create a cadre
of loyal bumiputeras, Daim's corporate shock troops, to begin snaring the
many privatization contracts that soon would be secretly awarded by Dr. M's
regime. And for practice, Daim's boys cut their teeth on what then had been
the largest construction project of its day in Kuala Lumpur, the
UBN/Shangri-La hotel and office complex in the heart of the Golden Triangle.
But there has long been a major obstacle in Wan Azmi's career path -- the
Prime Minister. freeMalaysia isn't sure why Dr. M didn't take the same
shine to him as did Daim. We are even more puzzled as to why Daim
repeatedly has had to intervene on his former protégé's behalf with
Mahathir, who for some reason dislikes or deeply mistrusts Wan Azmi. Wan
Azmi remains among the few Daim dandies whom Dr. M hasn't accepted as his own.
Puzzled? Yes, we are. Clueless? No. Snippets from friends and acquaintances
of Wan Azmi, as well as from the good old KL grapevine, help explain the
troubled relationship:
First, but perhaps least important, Wan Azmi is a wily contrarian. Maybe
it's the Kelantanese in him. Enough said about that.
Wan Azmi has complained to just about everybody in the KL business
community who counts that he hasn't gotten a single, big payday
privatization award, which he deserves so much more than all the other
cronies and proxies of Dr. M and Daim, you see.
For a period, Wan Azmi had joined hands with investors from George Soros'
fund management organization. The relationship apparently ended before the
Asian financial crisis, but tell that to Mahathir. And never mind that
Daim, himself, tried to strike up business with Soros in the past.
Wan Azmi has been known to be openly critical of Dr. M, even at public
functions of the Malay Chambers of Commerce and Industry of Malaysia.
Problem was that he was most critical of Mahathir when he was president of
chamber in the early 1990s and with Dr. M present.
Nor has Wan Azmi been the sort of sycophantic corporate diplomat that Dr. M
likes to recruit as part of his entourage for trips abroad. While president
of the Malay Chamber, he was reported to have dissed the Mahathir
administration's manipulation of the New Economic Policy before a gathering
of Turkish businessmen and political leaders in Istanbul.
These alone would be reasons enough for the intensely paranoid Dr. M to
take an immediate and lasting dislike to Wan Azmi. God knows Mahathir has
cast aside other men and a few women for less. But freeMalaysia thinks that
there is a more fundamental reason for Mahathir's unwillingness to advance
Wan Azmi's career -- Wan Azmi's father, former Supreme Court Judge Wan
Hamzah Wan Mohamed Salleh.
Younger readers of freeMalaysia might not be familiar with Wan Azmi's
bapak. They certainly haven't been taught anything in school about the 1988
role Tan Sri Wan Hamzah played in attempting to prevent Dr. M from
eviscerating the last vestiges of judicial independence and integrity. And
it was because he and his fellow honest judges lost the battle -- not that
they stood a chance of winning -- that today's Malaysian judiciary is
widely regarded as among the most corrupt and least competent in the
Commonwealth.
To recap the events of 1988 -- the culmination of Dr. M's despicable
three-year campaign to crush his political rivals and critics -- and Tan
Sri Wan Hamzah's part in unsuccessfully stopping Mahathir's intrigues,
freeMalaysia will be brief. Wan Azmi's father and four of his Supreme Court
colleagues were suspended, charged with "gross misbehavior" and forced to
face a kangaroo, government-appointed tribunal, impaneled to consider their
dismissals.
Basically, the five jurists, acting legally and bravely, temporarily
blocked an earlier and separate -- but equally rigged -- tribunal from
delivering its findings on the judicial actions and statements of former
Lord President Tun Mohamed Salleh Abas to Malaysia's king. Tun Salleh,
nonetheless, was later sacked by the king, accepting the allegations of and
acting under the advice of Dr. M, even though Malaysia's highest judge
refused to appear before or cooperate with the so-called jury of his peers.
His colleagues' temporary restraining order merely delayed the inevitable
firing.
It was Tun Salleh's successor, Tan Sri Abdul Hamid Omar, who filed the
charges against the five Supreme Court Justices for issuing the restraining
order. (Bear in mind that it was Tan Sri Hamid who was chairman of the
tribunal that determined Tun Salleh's fate.) Two of the jurists were fired,
while Tan Sri Wan Hamzah and the other two judges were cleared of all
charges and reinstated.
Though found not guilty, Tan Sri Wan Hamzah was deeply embittered by the
viciousness of Dr. M's campaign against the judiciary's independence and of
the corrupt, sorry state to which Mahathir drove the Malaysian courts. Upon
retiring, Wan Azmi's father became an avid supporter of Parti Islam
se-Malaysia, or PAS, and an articulate campaigner against the corruption
and injustice of the Mahathir administration and the ruling Barisan coalition.
For all these reasons and perhaps more, Wan Azmi was never able to navigate
his yearned-for transition from businessman to governmental leader. For a
while, he had hoped to be appointed Governor of Bank Negara. After all, he
had become the youngest banking chief in Malaysia's history, when at 35
years of age he was named president and chief executive of the nation's
largest bank, Malayan Banking Bhd. That was in 1985, thanks to his
appointment orchestrated by first-time Finance Minister Daim. But because
of the job's time-consuming demands and pressing family obligations, Wan
Azmi resigned from the post after only 19 months and abandoned any hope of
heading the central bank.
And there was plenty of chatter in the mid-1990s about Wan Azmi, after
having established some political credentials as the elected head of the
Malay Chamber, being positioned to run for a safe seat under Dr. M's United
Malays National Organization. Then after a brief interval, so went the
gossip, he would be appointed Finance Minister.
Former Finance Minister (and now jailed rival of Dr. M) Anwar Ibrahim was
said to be all for Wan Azmi as his successor, as long as he was given a
new, suitable portfolio, such as Home Affairs. And fM can't imagine Daim
objecting. What could be better than to have his star protégé holding the
most important regulatory post in the nation, especially for a market
wheeler-dealer like himself? But Dr. M would have none of it; no room would
be made for Wan Azmi in his regime. And that was that.
Wan Azmi, say acquaintances, didn't take rejection easily. His remarks
about Dr. M became even more caustic. But his loyalty to Daim remained as
firm as ever. And Malaysia's network of corporate insiders was well aware
of their unshakeable bond, not weakened in the least by Dr. M's rebuff of
Wan Azmi's.
Indeed, in the 1990s, Wan Azmi flourished in the widely recognized role as
the initial sounding board for corporate deals. Would Daim balk? the
country's deal makers asked him. Would he reject? Would he insist on his
usual cut? And, later, what about Anwar? Would he approve the deal? Could
Anwar get the Securities Commission to accept it? It was and still is an
enviable position that Wan Azmi cut out for himself, with the help of Daim.
And it went even deeper than that.
Wan Azmi also was on hand to settle disputes within Daim's ever-expanding
syndicate. The resulting settlement deals proved lucrative, such as the
time in 1990 when Wan Azmi's property-and-timber group Land & General Bhd.
stepped in to settle a corporate brawl between Berjaya Bhd. chief Tan Sri
Vincent Tan Chee Yioun and Multi-Purpose Holdings Bhd. boss Lim Thian Kiat.
The feud settled, Land & General walked off with control of one of the
country's most promising residential property projects, MPHB's Sri
Damansara, on the outskirts of the Malaysian capital.
The Asian financial crisis has temporarily taken the wind out of Wan Azmi's
sails, as it has for many Malaysian businessmen, crony and un-crony alike.
It's been especially hard for him, as his Land & General's prospects depend
largely on a buoyant property market, the sector hardest hit by the crisis
and probably the slowest to pull out of the recession.
In typical Wan Azmi fashion, he spared no one in placing the blame for the
property market's dismal outlook, including himself and the Mahathir
regime, in a paper he delivered a year ago before Malaysia's annual
National Real Estate Convention. He said that mistakes were made by:
"Bankers who force-fed us with too much credit; Governments who allowed us
to convert too much land and approved too many projects; Buyers who failed
to keep their promise to be around at our sales launches; and leaders who
promised the music would never stop. Our guilt as developers was the guilt
of naivete and our mistake was the mistake of innocence!"
Still, analysts reckon that Land & General will be able to hold life and
limb together, thanks largely to government-mandated low interest rates and
the group's attractive 10,000-acre land bank. It's Wan Azmi's personal
business forays that have analysts worried, such as golf courses and
bungalows in Portugal; mining operations in Australia and elsewhere; his
island resort of Malacca; a bank in Mauritius; a bunch of tiny
manufacturing companies in his home state of Kelantan; and so on.
freeMalaysia is a bit more sanguine about Wan Azmi's survivability. His
smarts and business know-how should see him through. Besides, Daim isn't
likely to abandon his finest protégé. Would Batman ever forsake Robin?

0 条评论:
发表评论
订阅 博文评论 [Atom]
<< 主页